First Impression: Holmes of Kyoto

When Aoi Mashiro walks into Kura, an antiques store in Kyoto she doesn’t find the owner there, or the owner’s son. Instead, she’s greeted by Kiyotaka Yagashira, a graduate student known to the locals as “Holmes.” Although young and serving as an apprentice, Holmes is no novice—his knowledge of antiques and ability to discover a forgery (and make deductions based upon the information presented to him) is extraordinary. And it appears that Aoi—who takes a job at the shop—has an eye for antiques, too, which will come in handy and she and Holmes solve related mysteries.

So, let’s make Holmes a handsome 22-year-old, Watson a 16-year-old high school girl, and Moriarty an antique counterfeiter? Sounds very much like anime to do so, and you know what? I think it’s going to work. There appears to be enough there in the world of antiques—interesting insights about historic and otherwise significant objects and mysterious that can be woven through them—to create stories for this series. And Aoi and Holmes themselves aren’t replicants of Oreki and Chitanda from Hyouka or the leaders of other related series; there’s a slight uptick in maturity based both on age and how the two interact in a more subtle, flirty way than in other shows. It’s not the quick wit of some British work, but there’s enough here to push this show solidly into seinen territory, which means that I’m very interested to see where this all goes (though it doesn’t hurt that I’ve been watching a bit of BBC Sherlock recently).

Holmes of Kyoto can be streamed on Crunchyroll.

TWWK

Husband. Dad. Occasionally Korean. Enjoys Star Wars, ASOIAF, and Meg Ryan movies. Tweets before proofreading. Ghibli. Oregairuuuuu. Jesus is King.

4 thoughts on “First Impression: Holmes of Kyoto

  1. I found this first episode a little flat but I had fairly strong expectations. That said, I’m still kind of hopeful for the series I just kind of hope future episodes have a bit more happening in them as this one seemed very relaxed.

    1. I came in with NOT expectations, which is maybe why I appreciated it. Still, I’m with you—I’m no sold that the “action” in this series will ever be terrifically interesting, and if not, I probably won’t continue to tune in.

  2. Overall looking forward to this series. I think the strength of the first episode was the interplay between our two main characters. The characters were rather flat and the plot neat but unexceptional. Though I think this has the potential to change…

    And kudos for the Hyouka reference!

Leave a Reply