A couple of weeks ago, we asked you to name a series that you love, but isn’t an especially good series, nor especially terrible. It’s just there, one in an endless landscape of anime. And because it’s caught in that vast middle, your choice may be lost to time, a series that is rarely discussed anymore as so many new anime become easily accessible each season. But that doesn’t mean it’s not valuable to you—and if given a chance, that series might become a favorite for someone else.
You responded to our question and gave us plenty of series to consider. Here are just a few of your answers to that question: What’s a completely average anime that you love?
1. Fairy Tail
These might be fighting words, but I think Micah hit the nail on the head: Fairy Tail is average, but incredibly lovable.
The comradery and characters, especially the interactions between Natsu, Gray, Lucy, and Ezra, have always been treasured in my heart ever since I first watched Fairy Tail. pic.twitter.com/32j1uOYCnr
— Micah Marshall (@micah_angus) July 26, 2020
2. Wasteful Days of High School Girls
I have a feeling that I would love this series, too!
Definitely Wasteful Days of High School Girls. It’s nothing spectacular but I just about keeled over with laugher the whole way through.
— mybestfriendsbestseller (@KatherineGogh) July 28, 2020
3. My Bride is Mermaid
A lot of times it’s those “first anime” that we treasure, even if we find out later that they aren’t the highest quality productions.
Does Seto No Hanayome count as average? It was the first anime I watched that got me into anime for good, and it was hilarious!
— E. (@sillellis) July 24, 2020
4. Nagi no Asakura
Our man Josh couldn’t agree more with Victor’s assessment.
YES!!! YES!!!! Agreed!! 100% Agreed!!! pic.twitter.com/4ZgnM7C8Wj
— Beneath the Tangles (@AnimeTangles) July 25, 2020
5. Hand Maid May
An old school selection, tweeted out by the translator of the Tenchi Muyo light novel translations!
I think "Hand Maid May" qualifies for me.
— AstroNerdBoy (@AstroNerdBoy) July 23, 2020
6. Azumanga Daioh
I have to disagree here…I think Azumanga Daioh is way, way WAY above average. Am I alone in this assessment?!
Azumanga Daioh, it was so mundane, so funny, so cute. Great characters, great fun, I even got real misty at he end of that show. pic.twitter.com/mcT45mFpah
— That X-Men Guy – TheYanni (also Kamen Rider) (@theyanni) July 24, 2020
7. Just Because
Definitely a series that you can fall in love with.
— Kellogg's Vinyl Krackles™ (@Sir_Lanian) July 23, 2020
8. Steel Angel Kurumi
Justin, I think a whole lot of otaku would say the exact same.
For the life of me, I can't point to anything that Steel Angel Kurumi does at a level better than "competent" but I do enjoy the show wholly and unreservedly.
— Justin Porter (@HavenRacewayJP) July 23, 2020
Finally, our man Jeskai gives us five recommendations after asking us to provide a better definition of average. So here they are, with quantitative data!
9-13: If Her Flag Breaks, Happiness!, Seven Senses of the Reunion, Cinderella Nine, Tamayomi
These are the most "average" (in terms of MAL rating) anime I like. Oddly, the two sports anime I've enjoyed are the lowest rated of all. Maybe I'm weird for liking cute girls doing baseball things?
— Jeskai Angel (@JeskaiAngel) July 24, 2020
We received other answers as well through our other platforms. Thanks especially to those who replied on our original post and through Facebook! I especially encourage you check out some of the great responses we received through the latter by clicking below.
Thanks to all who responded, and to everyone, I hope enjoy watching these anime that are perhaps not-so-average after all!
Featured illustration by 大家 (reprinted w/permission).